A group of businesses is
preparing a legal challenge to prevent the government from beginning Brexit
negotiations without an act of parliament.
The action, brought by law
firm Mishcon de Reya, would potentially complicate Britain's path to leaving
the EU, given that a majority of MPs were in favour of remaining and many have
continued to speak in favour of maintaining access to the single market.
Candidates in the
Conservative leadership election have so far treated the start of negotiations
as within the next prime minister's discretion.
Theresa May, favourite in
the leadership debate, told ITV's Peston on Sunday that she would only activate
Article 50, the formal notification of Britain's intention to leave, once the
government's negotiating stance was clear. That would mean the legal trigger
would not occur this calendar year, a stance supported by the justice secretary
Michael Gove.
In contrast, two other
candidates in the Conservative leadership election, Andrea Leadsom and Liam
Fox, have said they would begin formal negotiations in September or shortly
after. EU leaders have also said negotiations should begin once a new prime
minister is in place.
"It's about giving
certainty to businesses," Ms Leadsom told the BBC's Andrew Marr Show.
"We just need to get on with it."
Once Article 50 is
activated, the UK would have to leave the EU within two years — unless all
other member states consented to an extension.
Mischon de Reya's legal
challenge follows an article by three academics, Nick Barber, Tom Hickman and
Jeff King. The article argued that the government would be violating
parliamentary sovereignty if it activated Article 50 on its own — because it
would render redundant rights established by the European Communities Act of
1972.
"In our constitution,
parliament gets to make this decision, not the prime minister," the
academics said. In addition, an activation without a parliamentary vote would
not be effective, because Article 50 of the Lisbon treaty requires a state to
act "in accordance with its own constitutional requirements".
Kasra Nouroozi, a partner at
Mishcon de Reya, said: "The result of the referendum is not in doubt, but
we need a process that follows UK law to enact it. Article 50 simply cannot be
invoked without a full debate and vote in parliament."
The firm, which has not
disclosed the names of its clients in the action, said that government lawyers
argued that the executive did have the power to activate Article 50.
No comments:
Post a Comment